"Provides a glimpse into the beginning of some of Tolkien's most iconic creations. From the camaraderie of the fellowship in The Lord of the Rings to the desolate landscapes of Mordor, readers familiar with Tolkien's work will find intriguing connections between his wartime experiences and the fantasy realms he would go on to craft." - Geek-Network.com

"Succeeds in shedding light on a crucial but often overlooked period in the life of a literary giant. The graphic novel captures the essence of Tolkien's wartime service, offering readers a visual and emotional journey that enhances their appreciation for the man behind the fantasy masterpieces." --GEEK-NETWORK.COM

"The art has a clean and classic look, with visual elements of light and darkness neatly paralleling the story arc. Though diehard Tolkien fans might wish for a more thorough treatment, this still satisfies." - Publishers Weekly