"The energy Cash brings to her comics is palpable, but her more relaxed moments shine the brightest, giving us the rare comic that actually manages to feel cool." - The Comics Journal

"This is what I want from comics. In an album-sized format, Caroline Cash gives us hilarious and insightful queer short stories drawing on her own life experiences. A frequent comparison is to Clowes, but I'd argue Cash is operating in a totally different world. Her cartooning oscillates between several distinct styles, jumping from one to the other like it's nothing. There are influences from the underground, manga, and zine culture that feel wholly unique from anything else out there." -Cy Beltran, The Beat "Best Comics of 2023"

"When Clowes started Eightball, it was a conscious and highly confident redirection from what he had been doing before. You could tell that this was a cartoonist who was hitting his stride. The same is true for Cash with PeePee PooPoo. As much as she's laughing at outdated comics conventions and attitudes and uses that as an initial hook, the real value of these comics is seeing how confidently she goes from memoir to slice-of-life to absurdist humor to observational comics." - Rob Clough, SOLRAD